Palmer Lane Maple — Craving a creemee? Join the crowd at this popular roadside spot, where pure maple syrup imbues soft-serve swirls with Vermont’s famous flavor. Don't miss the housemade maple sprinkles.
Other Finalists (Inside Chittenden County)
- Burlington Bay Market & Café
- Mr. Creemee
- The Village Scoop
Vermont Cookie Love — The sweet-toothed swing by the "Love Shack" year-round for freshly baked cookies, but in summer the greater attraction is smooth, thick creemees made from high-butterfat Vermont dairy. New in 2026, a second outpost opened in Middlebury.
Other Finalists (Outside Chittenden County)
- Canteen Creemee Company
- Morse Farm Maple Sugarworks
- Red Hen Baking Co.
- Silloway Maple
